Post a Review of A Silver Thread
Name:
Email:
Website:
Comments:
To prevent spam, please prove you're a human by selecting only the photos of cats below. Then click the "Submit Review" button and your review will be posted.
 

Note: Positive and constructive reviews are welcome. Reviews that bash a story or author will be deleted. Review Guide.
Each entry can only hold up to 3,000 characters. If your review is longer, please split it into multiple posts.

21  Sarah posted on Apr 19, 2008
DUDE, it's freaking beautiful. You posted it here a long time ago and I'm not sure you're gonna read this comment, but I had to write it.
(I'm sorry for any spelling mistakes I probably have, I'm not American.)
20  kara posted on Sep 22, 2007
perfection. I'm going ot say that that is what really happened. Thank you for the closureo n what the note said. :) I can die almost happy. Spuffy needs to get together for the full bliss. lol.
19  Deb posted on Feb 15, 2006
Lovely connection.
18  too bad posted on Mar 4, 2004
I guess we'll never know what the note really said. But, by watch those last eposodes i don't get the feeling it said that I wish it had though
17  Connie posted on May 28, 2003
Excellent why could the show end that way. He needs to know he was loved.
16  Jeanette posted on May 18, 2003 | I wish........
Sniff........
Now please write the meeting on the other side of the hellmouth. (GROVEL, GROVEL, GROVEL)
15  cousinjean posted on May 18, 2003
See, now that's why I'm your bitch. If only that was what the note really said. Sigh.
14  spikealicious posted on May 17, 2003 | www.spikealicious.com
Loved the angst of the moment, the yearning, the love. They should have had that, they would have, if it were going to be one of their last nights they ever thought they might have together.

You did the Buffy-speak in the note perfectly! She wrote, like she speaks, although, of course, in the note, was able to say what she couldn't out loud, but you had her inflections.
13  bailunrui posted on May 14, 2003 | http://lovebites.bailunrui.com
DP... just when I don't think it's possible to love you anymore, you go and write a fic like this. You rock.
12  InsaneVampiress posted on May 12, 2003
This was fantastic writing. It was also very sad, but so sweet. Trying to remember him...what an awesome piece of fanfiction you have here.
11  PixenVixen posted on May 11, 2003
Buffy's sudden, awful premonition of Spike's self-sacrifice causes her to desperately run her fingers over his face, memorizing every line and curve of his countenance and that aching look of love in his earnest blue eyes - that moment was absolutely HEARTBREAKING. Sob.
10  Nebula posted on May 10, 2003 | http://www.geocities.com/nebula_authoress
Your story was awesome! I have to admit, it made me cry. It was the sweetest Buffy/Spike moment that I've read in a long time. It was absolutely perfect. Please, keep up the good work!!!
9  WilliamsLove posted on May 9, 2003
thats so awesome!! im really really happy!! so beautiful, its what i hoped the note read!! please more, such a wonderful start. :)
8  Isabella posted on May 9, 2003
Bite your tongue! I will curl up into a ball and speak in short, non-commital phrases before I eventually DIE if I don't get to know what was written in the actual letter! But I just loved your version. It was really wonderful. How cliche, but I think you get me. *grins*
7  Julie posted on May 9, 2003
Thanks, DP - a lovely story, to give us more background on what happened between them. Plus I like your version of the note Buffy left him - ME will probably never let us know what was in it, so thank you for sharing your version!
6  Viola posted on May 9, 2003
Oh, I was *so* hoping others would notice how long that note was and that wonderful fic writers would seize the opportunity. And you did! Thanks so much, it was beautiful. *sigh* *sniffle*
5  Vixen posted on May 9, 2003
Beautiful story. I loved it.
4  Susan posted on May 9, 2003
Lovely, lovely, lovely... Thank you
3  Kate posted on May 9, 2003
Favorite line: "Spike - pair up with Kennedy for the remained of the apocalypse." I just love how it is implied that *that* could be one of the worst ways Buffy could punish Spike. lol Which is a perfect example of the wonderful humor threaded through such a poingant story that is so true to the voices of both Buffy and Spike. I can absolutely see this moment happening in the in between time that we never saw on screen. Thank you for sharing.

Oh, ps - thanks for including the "note." It thrilled me to no end that she left him and have been pondering what exactly she might have written in it. I definitely like your version. :)
2  Mona posted on May 9, 2003
*Gah*

Ok, new attempt after overcoming the feeling of being overwhelmed:
a gorgeous moment and something that, to my mind, both should have happened and could have happenend; this really constitutes a credible background for Buffy's renewed strength and her confident decision to tackle the First in the vineyard on her own.
Thanks for giving us this most satisfying, yet realistic scene.
& :-)
1  hold_that_thought posted on May 9, 2003
This is absolutely wonderful, sweet but not too sweet, with just the right amount of subtle funny to make it truly Buffy-esque. Just lovely.

Back to A Silver Thread